> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://newsanek.com/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# Madhya Pradesh High Court pulls up State over fictitious AI-generated case citation
- URL: https://newsanek.com/mp-high-court-slams-state-fictitious-ai-case-law/
- Published: 2026-11-19T12:36:01.000Z
- Updated: 2026-11-19T12:50:48.000Z
- Description: The Madhya Pradesh High Court criticised the State government for citing a Supreme Court judgment that does not exist. The case was in a reply to a petition by a dismissed former police officer. The Court said lawyers must check every citation before filing.
- Author: Kumar Ujjwal
- Tags: India, Madhya Pradesh, Explainer, #state-madhya-pradesh, #state-desk, #region-central, #running, #sm-42, #smemo-surprise

The Madhya Pradesh High Court has strongly criticised the State government for citing a Supreme Court judgment that does not exist.

The mistake came in a reply filed in a petition challenging the dismissal of a former police officer.

Justice Vivek Kumar Singh said the reply was drafted in a "callous and irresponsible manner." The Court found that the judgment cited by the State was fictitious.

![MP HIGH COURT INDORE - panoramio - Gyanendra Singh Chau…](https://newsanek.com/content/images/2026/11/mp-high-court-slams-state-fictitious-ai-case-law-a43f16.jpg)

Representative photo: MP HIGH COURT INDORE - panoramio - Gyanendra Singh Chau…. Photo: Gyanendra\_Singh\_Chau… / [Wikimedia Commons](https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File%3AMP%5FHIGH%5FCOURT%5FINDORE%5F-%5Fpanoramio%5F-%5FGyanendra%5FSingh%5FChau%E2%80%A6.jpg?ref=newsanek.com), CC BY 3.0

The State had relied on a case titled "State of Andhra Pradesh vs. S.S.

Mohammad Nisar." The citation given for it belonged to a different ruling, on an entirely different subject.

### Key points

- The High Court said the State's reply cited a case that does not exist.
- The Court said the State appeared to have used AI tools to draft the reply.
- The case is about the 2024 dismissal of Piyush Mani Tiwari, a former police officer.
- The Court sent its judgment to the State Law Secretary and the Advocate General.

## So how did a fake case reach a court reply?

The Court said it was clearly visible that the State had blindly used Artificial Intelligence (AI) tools.

This led to a made-up case name linked to an unrelated citation.

The judge said pleadings before a Constitutional Court are solemn documents.

The Court strictly warned the State against what it called "reckless practices."

## Why does this matter for the case and for others?

The Bench said adding fake case laws wastes precious judicial time.

It also said such conduct borders on actively misleading the Court.

The petition was filed by Piyush Mani Tiwari.

He had been serving as an Acting Sub-Inspector at the State Situation Room in Bhopal when he was dismissed in 2024.

The State said a cleaner or sweeper had accused him of behaving objectionably with her.

Tiwari said he was dismissed without any departmental enquiry.

These are allegations, and the State's handling of the matter is part of the court's record.

## What happens next after the Court's warning?

The Court sent a copy of its judgment to the State Law Secretary and the Advocate General.

The Advocate General's office is expected to make sure all legal points and citations are checked before they are sworn on affidavit.

Explainer

### What happened before

- In 2024, the State dismissed Piyush Mani Tiwari, who was serving as an Acting Sub-Inspector at the State Situation Room in Bhopal.
- The State acted after a cleaner or sweeper accused him of behaving objectionably with her.
- Tiwari challenged the dismissal, saying no preliminary or regular departmental enquiry was held.

### Why it matters

The court said fake case laws in official court papers waste judicial time and can mislead the Court. Lawyers must check every citation before filing.

---

### Sources

- [Bar and Bench: Madhya Pradesh High Court slams State for citing fictitious case law generated by AI tool](https://www.barandbench.com/news/madhya-pradesh-high-court-slams-state-for-citing-fictitious-case-law-generated-by-ai-tool?ref=newsanek.com)