Forensic reports are scientific tests that help courts decide criminal cases.
In Maharashtra, many of these reports are taking a long time.
Figures published by the state's Directorate of Forensic Science Laboratories (DFSL) show that 54,313 cases were pending at the beginning of October.
Of these, 14,295 were at the laboratory in Kalina, in Mumbai.
Key points
- 54,313 forensic cases were pending at the start of October.
- 377 of 1,486 sanctioned posts at DFSL are vacant, about one in four.
- Cyber forensics and the TASI division together hold nearly three-fourths of the backlog.
- The state has approved 220 contract experts for three years.
So why does this matter for ordinary people?
Delays in forensic reports can change how a case ends.
In one case, a doctor examined an eight-year-old boy who was allegedly sexually assaulted.
The final medical opinion depended on forensic reports.
Those reports were not placed before the trial court. On October 21, a special POCSO court acquitted the accused.
POCSO refers to the law that protects children from sexual offences.
In another case, police filed a charge sheet in an alleged extortion plot targeting comedian Kapil Sharma.
The accused later sought bail.
The prosecution told a Mumbai sessions court on March 10 that the forensic report on his voice sample was still awaited.
The court granted him bail.
Which labs are under the most pressure?
The backlog is not spread evenly. The cyber forensics division alone has 30,387 pending cases.
The Toxicology and Analytical Science Investigation (TASI) division has 9,964.
Together, they make up nearly three-fourths of the statewide backlog.
Graphic: News Anek, from the facts in this report
In September, the cyber division received 723 cases but examined only 302. TASI received 305 cases and examined 107.
In both divisions, more cases came in than were cleared.
Some divisions did improve. The DNA division cut its pending cases from 2,268 to 1,670 during September.
The biology division also reduced its pendency, from 4,898 to 4,099.
What is the government doing about it?
The state government has recently approved contractual recruitment of 220 forensic experts for three years.
These posts are meant to address the backlog in the cyber and TASI divisions.
Delay does not always affect the result.
In a POCSO case decided on May 2, an expert said DNA analysis of samples from September and October 2021 began only in June 2022.
The expert said the results were still reliable because the samples were kept at the prescribed 4 degrees Celsius.
The court accepted the DNA evidence.
Explainer
What happened before
- In one POCSO case, a special court acquitted the accused on October 21 after the forensic reports were not placed before the trial court.
- In a separate case, the prosecution told a Mumbai sessions court on March 10 that the forensic report on a voice sample was still awaited, and the court granted bail.
Why it matters
Forensic reports are often needed to decide a criminal case, so delays can affect how cases end for victims and accused people alike.
What to watch next
- The state government has approved contractual recruitment of 220 forensic experts for three years to reduce the backlog in the cyber and TASI divisions.