The Orissa High Court has ordered the Odisha government to pay 15 lakh rupees to the family of an undertrial prisoner.
The prisoner, Charan Behera, died inside a jail in Ganjam district in July 2023.
An undertrial is a person held in custody while his case is still pending in court.
Behera was arrested on July 11, 2023, in a theft case. He was then lodged in Bhanjanagar Special Sub-Jail.
Four days later, on July 15, he was taken to a hospital in a jail ambulance. Doctors declared him dead.
- July 11, 2023Behera was arrested in a theft case and lodged in Bhanjanagar Special Sub-Jail.
- July 15He was taken to a hospital in a jail ambulance, where doctors declared him dead.
- November 11Justice Biraja Prasanna Satapathy ordered Rs 15 lakh compensation for the family.
Graphic: News Anek, from the facts in this report
A post-mortem found many injuries, including extensive bruising on his left arm, side and back.
Key points
- The Orissa High Court ordered 15 lakh rupees compensation for the family of Charan Behera.
- Behera died in Bhanjanagar Special Sub-Jail in Ganjam district in July 2023.
- A judicial inquiry said he was killed inside the jail, allegedly by a fellow inmate.
- The court also ordered a government job for his wife.
So how did the death happen inside the jail?
A judicial inquiry concluded that Behera died a homicidal death inside the jail.
The report said a life convict and jail watcher, Ajay Naik, allegedly hit him with a plastic pipe.
These are allegations. The report does not mean a court has found Naik guilty.
Three undertrial prisoners in the same ward told the inquiry officer that Naik had severely assaulted Behera.
The jail medical officer and the post-mortem findings supported their statements.
Why did the court blame the jail authorities?
The court held that negligence by jail authorities led to his death.
The inquiry officer also raised serious doubts about the conduct of senior jail officials.
A senior jail official had attributed the death to cardiac arrest.
The medical officer denied telling him that, and said Behera had multiple injuries before he was shifted to hospital.
The inquiry also recorded allegations that a jail warder and the life convict tried to influence a witness.
What did the court order, and what happens next?
Justice Biraja Prasanna Satapathy issued the order in a judgment on November 11.
Of the 15 lakh rupees, 10 lakh goes to the wife.
The remaining 5 lakh rupees will be kept in a fixed deposit for six years.
The account is in the name of the couple's minor daughter.
The court also said basic human rights are part of fundamental rights. It said old defences cannot take those rights away from a prisoner.
Explainer
What happened before
- Charan Behera was arrested on July 11, 2023, in a theft case and sent to judicial custody.
- On July 15, he was taken to a hospital from Bhanjanagar Special Sub-Jail, where doctors declared him dead.
- A judicial inquiry later concluded that he died a homicidal death inside the jail premises.
Why it matters
Deaths in custody raise questions about how safely people are kept in jails. The court said prisoners keep their fundamental rights, even inside jail.
What to watch next
- The court has ordered a government job for the deceased's wife, along with 10 lakh rupees to her.
- The remaining 5 lakh rupees will stay in a fixed deposit in the name of the couple's minor daughter for six years.